← All Cases

Ruth Downing

No photo on file
Date February 2, 1956
Age 24 years old
Location Surfside, FL
Type Homicide
Status Closed

Case Summary


Ruth Downing, 24, was found dead on February 2, 1956 in Surfside, on Biscaya Drive, at a location only one minute's walk from where Danny Goldman would be kidnapped a decade later in 1966.

The body was discovered directly across a small residential street from the home of Sam Tucker, a top-tier organized crime figure. Tucker lived in the only home within 75 feet. Tucker and Meyer Lansky were partners in casinos in Havana and Las Vegas. There were only 8 homes on Biscaya Island at the time.

Ms. Downing was found wearing a bright red dress in an empty residential lot on Biscaya Island. Her body was discovered at 8:10 AM by Surfside patrolman Officer Kenneth Galusha. Death appeared to have occurred at approximately 3:00 AM. Mr. and Mrs. Tucker were at home, and reported nothing unusual.

Dade County Sheriff's detectives Manson Hill and T.A. Buchanan took over the case. Ms. Downing had been stabbed several times with a long knife. No weapon was found, no arrests were made, and no trials ever occurred.

The case was widely covered in the press as the "Lady in Red" case. Randolph Herring was alleged to have committed this and many other crimes. He was found to be severely mentally ill, placed under hypnosis, sent to a state mental hospital, kept in confinement for many years, then brought back, declared sane and not guilty by virtue of insanity, and released.

No one ever faced charges in the death of Ruth Downing.

Document Archives


Have information about this case?

Submit a Tip